If you’ve ever played White Elephant, you know it’s not your typical gift exchange. Instead of thoughtfully picking a present for someone specific, the goal is to bring a gift that’s universally appealing, a little surprising, maybe even a bit funny or luxe—and absolutely steal-worthy.
During the game, everyone draws numbers, picks gifts, unwraps them one by one, and, of course, steals the ones they want most. The best White Elephant gifts strike that sweet spot between practical, unique, and delightfully extra.
This year, if you want to bring the gift that everyone keeps trying to swap for, we’ve rounded up the perfect line-up—all between $50 and $100, all fabulous, and all guaranteed to spark a friendly holiday tug-of-war.
The White Elephant Gift Guide They’ll Fight For
1. SEALD™ Face Tape Smoothing Strips & Forehead Wrinkle Patches
Perfect for the beauty enthusiast, skincare minimalist, or the friend who jokes about “resting wrinkle face.” These smoothing strips and patches deliver overnight results and feel like a spa-night upgrade wrapped in a tiny package.
2. SEALD™ Mouth Tape (for better sleep)
Hear us out—this is funny enough for White Elephant but genuinely life-changing for nasal breathing and deeper rest. Expect laughter followed by someone saying, “Wait… I actually want to try this.”
3. Emi Jay Big Effing Clip
This hair accessory is the ultimate blend of cool-girl aesthetic and everyday practicality. It’s oversized, chic, and looks good on literally everyone. A guaranteed crowd-pleaser.
4. Emi Jay Popstar Clips
For the friend who always has perfect hair (or wants it), these clips bring effortless glamour to any look. Cute, durable, and instantly giftable.
5. SIDIA The Hand Serum
A luxury moment for hardworking hands. This serum is sleek, nourishing, and elevates the simple act of moisturizing. The kind of White Elephant gift that gets stolen at least twice.
6. De La Heart The Facial Dry Brush
A self-care staple that turns any bathroom into an at-home spa. It’s detoxifying, energizing, and looks gorgeous sitting on a vanity.
7. Wonder Valley Gua Sha
Timeless, sculpting, de-puffing, and beloved by basically everyone on the internet. It’s a beauty ritual and a moment of calm, all in one elegant little stone.
8. Doré Le Baume
Hydrating, multi-purpose, and effortlessly luxe—this balm feels like a tiny piece of vacation tucked into a stocking-sized package.
9. Fancy Peasant Honey Lavender
This dreamy Honey Lavender blend is a decadent, artisanal treat made for foodies, tea lovers, and anyone who appreciates a little luxury in their pantry. Drizzle it on toast, swirl it into tea, pair it with cheese—it’s the kind of gift that feels special, indulgent, and totally unexpected in the best way.
10. Saint Jane Mini’s
The perfect mini luxuries. These travel-friendly skincare heroes make any routine feel celestial—ideal for jet-setters, skincare lovers, or anyone who needs a glowing pick-me-up.
If you’re showing up to this year’s White Elephant determined to be the person with the best gift in the pile, this lineup has you covered. All under $100, all beautifully thoughtful, and all guaranteed to bring smiles (and strategic stealing).
Wrap it cute, place it under the tree, and get ready for the chaos.
No products in the cart.